Forum:SH:Star Wars Timelines sources

This page is an archive of a community-wide discussion. This page is no longer live. Further comments or questions on this topic should be made in a new Senate Hall page rather than here so that this page is preserved as a historic record. TanDivoInsignia-SenateMurders Anıl Şerifoğlu (talk) 21:10, 10 September 2023 (UTC)
Forums > Senate Hall archive > SH:Star Wars Timelines sources

I've just begun to notice hundreds of pages erroneously list Star Wars: Timelines as a source based on the assumption that Star Wars Galaxy Map was to be included as part of Star Wars: Timelines once the book was published.

This appears to be due to the erroneous announcement here: StarWars.com SWCC 2022: 7 Things We Learned from the Lucasfilm Publishing Behind the Page Panel on StarWars.com (backup link).

Is it possible to somehow generate a list of all pages that had Star Wars: Timelines anticipatorily added (prior to it's publication in April, 2023) as a source, so that these pages can have their sources correctly ammended from Star Wars: Timelines to Star Wars Galaxy Map? LadyNeret (talk) 03:52, 31 July 2023 (UTC)

Discuss

  • In my opinion we should leave it as Star Wars: Timelines since the promotional poster was heavily tied to the book. Bonzane10 Sabine Starbird (holonet) 04:44, 31 July 2023 (UTC)
    • The problem with that is: that is not how sourcing works. We can't refer to something having appeared in Star Wars: Timelines if it never did. The Galaxy Map and Star Wars: Timelines are two distinct sources. LadyNeret (talk) 05:29, 31 July 2023 (UTC)
  • I think this might be the best source listing everything from the Galaxy Map, though it might be an issue since some of these are also mentioned in Timelines itself. Rsand 30 (talk) 04:53, 31 July 2023 (UTC)
    • Thanks, Rsand 30! I was aware of that source. It is missing a few systems and does have a few spelling mistakes but is a good start nonetheless. LadyNeret (talk) 05:29, 31 July 2023 (UTC)
      • By my count, Star Wars Galaxy Map has a total of 749 astronomical placements. LadyNeret (talk) 05:31, 31 July 2023 (UTC)
        • The wider problem is that once someone has added the erroneous Star Wars Timelines source to a plantary system page, other users seem to have run with it and propogated the incorrect assumed source to other pages connecting to that page. LadyNeret (talk) 05:41, 31 July 2023 (UTC)
          • In that case it will just be a time-consuming process to manually correct every astronomical location that has Timelines listed as a source if it was only ever on the Celebration map. Fan26 (Talk) 16:53, 31 July 2023 (UTC)
            • Already did the ones I've brought to status FWIW :P Imperators II(Talk) 17:55, 31 July 2023 (UTC)
  • Ah nice, a separate article for the map at last! Do we perchance also know exactly which portions of the map were included in Battles that Changed the Galaxy? Imperators II(Talk) 06:30, 31 July 2023 (UTC)
  • These sources should be corrected to the map where applicable, yeah. It would be erroneous to keep them on Timelines as that information is not in the book (so double checking it when writing/editing articles would be a waste of time) and it was only promotional material for it. The fact that it has its own article now cements that imo. - Thannus (DFaceG) (he/him) (talk) 23:48, 2 August 2023 (UTC)

The List

Alright, so these are all the canon entries in Category:Locations by grid square that list Timelines on the page. Due to the complexity of the change, I'm wary of doing a bot replacement, so I'm posting these here for manual review. Please feel free to remove them as you check them. Cade GalacticRepublicEmblem-Traced-TORkit Calrayn 16:55, 10 August 2023 (UTC)

  1. 3rd Moon
  2. Aaloth
  3. Aargonar
  4. Ab Dalis
  5. Abednedo (planet)
  6. Abyss/Canon
  7. Actlyon
  8. Adinax Nebula
  9. Aeos Prime
  10. Af'El
  11. Agaris
  12. Agoliba-Tu system
  13. Ahn Krantarium
  14. Ajan Kloss
  15. Alderaan
  16. Aleen
  17. Allanteen VI
  18. Aloxor
  19. Aloxor system
  20. Alpinn
  21. Alsakan
  22. Andelm IV
  23. Ando system
  24. Annaj system
  25. Anoat
  26. Anoat system
  27. Anthan Prime
  28. Anthan system
  29. Antillion
  30. Arantara
  31. Arbra
  32. Archeon Nebula
  33. Ardennia
  34. Aris
  35. Arkax Station
  36. Arthon
  37. Artiod system
  38. Arvaka Prime
  39. Ashas Ree
  40. Athulla
  41. Atrisia
  42. Atterra Bravo
  43. Atterra system
  44. Avedot
  45. Axxila III
  46. B'ankora homeworld
  47. Bakura
  48. Balmorra
  49. Balosar
  50. Bamayar
  51. Bar'leth
  52. Baraan-Fa
  53. Bardelberan 7
  54. Baroli
  55. Bastatha
  56. Bastion
  57. Batonn
  58. Batuu
  59. Bayora
  60. Beauchen
  61. Begamor
  62. Belderone
  63. Benath
  64. Benathy homeworld
  65. Benglor
  66. Bestine system
  67. Bilbringi
  68. Bimmisaari
  69. Birren
  70. Bith (planet)
  71. Bleuf
  72. Bogano
  73. Bonadan
  74. Borosk
  75. Botajef
  76. Botor
  77. Bracca
  78. Bracca system
  79. Bri'n
  80. Brighthome
  81. Brooksdion
  82. Burnin Konn
  83. Byss
  84. Caliban
  85. Calumdarian
  86. Candovant
  87. Cantonica
  88. Cardota
  89. Cardovyte
  90. Carida
  91. Carlac
  92. Carnelion IV
  93. Carosi Eight
  94. Castell
  95. Centori
  96. Cerberon system
  97. Cerea
  98. Chaaktil
  99. Chadawa
  100. Chadawa system
  101. Chagar IX
  102. Champat
  103. Chandar's Folly
  104. Chandrila
  105. Chardaan
  106. Charissia
  107. Chespea
  108. Chibbier
  109. Cholganna
  110. Chorin
  111. Chortose
  112. Chroman
  113. Chrome Citadel
  114. Cianap
  115. Citadel of Rur
  116. Ciutric
  117. Coachelle Prime
  118. Codia system
  119. Colla IV
  120. Colossus
  121. Cona
  122. Corellia
  123. Corosi 7
  124. Corulag
  125. Coruscant
  126. Courtsilius
  127. Crait
  128. Crait system
  129. Crul
  130. Crushank Nebulae
  131. Cuyacan
  132. Cyclor
  133. Cyclor Shipyards
  134. Cymoon
  135. Cymoon 1
  136. Cyrkon
  137. D'Qar
  138. DS-2 Death Star II Mobile Battle Station
  139. Daghee
  140. Dagobah
  141. Daivak
  142. Dallenor
  143. Dalna
  144. Dannamore
  145. Dantooine
  146. Dantooine system
  147. Darkknell system
  148. Dassal system
  149. Dathomir
  150. Daxam IV
  151. Death Star
  152. Del Zennis system
  153. Demir
  154. Derra
  155. Desevro
  156. Devaron
  157. Dinwa Prime
  158. Dotharian
  159. Dowut
  160. Drahgor III
  161. Dressel
  162. Dromondar Beta
  163. Dubraib
  164. Dulathia
  165. Durkteel
  166. Duro
  167. E'ronoh
  168. Eadu
  169. Edan II
  170. Eiram
  171. Eiram system
  172. Elessia
  173. Elom (planet)
  174. Elphrona
  175. Empress Teta
  176. Endor
  177. Endrias Minor
  178. Entralla
  179. Ephemera
  180. Eroudac
  181. Escalan
  182. Espinar
  183. Espirion
  184. Everbloom
  185. Everon
  186. Exegol
  187. Exodeen
  188. Farstey
  189. Fellio Asteroid Belt
  190. Felucia Medical Station HCTFF2
  191. Feriae Junction
  192. Fermic
  193. Fest
  194. Fex
  195. Florn
  196. Foerost
  197. Foless
  198. Fondor
  199. Forrn
  200. Forrn's moon
  201. Foundry
  202. Gad
  203. Galaan
  204. Galator III
  205. Galitan
  206. Galmerah
  207. Galov system
  208. Ganthel
  209. Garbage Moon of Maher
  210. Garel system
  211. Garqi
  212. Gatalenta
  213. Gattering
  214. Generis
  215. Genetia
  216. Geonosis
  217. Gheia Six
  218. Ghorman
  219. Glavis Ringworld
  220. Glee Anselm
  221. Gold system
  222. Golrath
  223. Gortus 4
  224. Grange
  225. Grava
  226. Gravity's Heart
  227. Great Forveen Nebula
  228. Griq
  229. Grizal
  230. Grysk homeworld
  231. Guat'a
  232. Gulhadar
  233. H'nemthe/Canon
  234. Haileap
  235. Hakotei
  236. Haneli
  237. Hapes
  238. Harloff Minor
  239. Hartaga system
  240. Hays Major
  241. Hays Minor
  242. Hebekrr Minor
  243. Hebekrr system
  244. Herdessa
  245. Heva
  246. Hevurion
  247. Hinari
  248. Hindle
  249. Hisseen
  250. Hissrich
  251. Hivebase-1
  252. Hok
  253. Honoghr
  254. Horain
  255. Horox III
  256. Hosnian
  257. Hosnian system
  258. Hosra
  259. Hovun IV
  260. Hubin
  261. Hyborea
  262. Hyborean Moon
  263. Hynestia Prime
  264. Hyperkarn
  265. Hypori
  266. Ielo
  267. Ikkrukk
  268. Iktotch
  269. Iloh
  270. Ilum
  271. Imvur
  272. Inusagi
  273. Inya Prime
  274. Iridonia
  275. Irudiru
  276. Irudiru system
  277. Ivarujar
  278. Jaelen
  279. Jaemus
  280. Jakku
  281. Jakku system
  282. Jalindi
  283. Japeal
  284. Jedha
  285. Jekara
  286. Jelucan
  287. Jeosyn
  288. Joh'Cire
  289. Judakann
  290. K43
  291. Kakra
  292. Kalarba
  293. Kalee
  294. Kaliida Nebula
  295. Kaliida Shoals Medical Center
  296. Kalki Nebula
  297. Kaller
  298. Karavis
  299. Karazak
  300. Kardoa
  301. Karkaris
  302. Kartoosh
  303. Kashyyyk
  304. Kelada
  305. Kerkoidia
  306. Ketz
  307. Kijimi
  308. Kinoss
  309. Kinyen
  310. Kirima
  311. Kiros
  312. Klytus V
  313. Kolkur
  314. Korrus
  315. Kreeling
  316. Kril'Dor
  317. Krownest
  318. Krystar
  319. Ktath'atn
  320. Kuat
  321. Kudo
  322. Kuliquo belt
  323. Kullgroon
  324. Kupoh
  325. Kupoh system
  326. Kur Nebula
  327. Lah'mu
  328. Lannik
  329. Lantillies
  330. Lanz Carpo
  331. Lasan
  332. Lechra
  333. Ledeve
  334. Lenahra
  335. Lenguin system
  336. Lessa-7
  337. Lianna
  338. Lianna system
  339. Linasals
  340. Liskan
  341. Livno III
  342. Livorno
  343. Loreth
  344. Lorrd
  345. Lost Souls
  346. Lothal system
  347. Lowik
  348. Luprora
  349. Lysatra
  350. Madurs
  351. Magaveene
  352. Maher
  353. Mahranee
  354. Maires
  355. Mako-Ta
  356. Mako-Ta Space Docks
  357. Malachor
  358. Malachor system
  359. Malastare
  360. Malpaz
  361. Mandalore
  362. Mantooine
  363. Marquinn
  364. Mathas
  365. Megalox Beta
  366. Melacon
  367. Melagawni
  368. Merj
  369. Merokia
  370. Mesula
  371. Mesulan Remnants Belt
  372. Metalorn
  373. Mikkia
  374. Milagro
  375. Minemoon
  376. Minfar
  377. Minos Cluster
  378. Mirrin Prime
  379. Mirrin system
  380. Mokivj
  381. Mol'leaj system
  382. Mollo Tanka
  383. Mon Cala
  384. Monsua Nebula
  385. Montross
  386. Mooga
  387. Moon of Drazkel
  388. Moon of Logal Ri
  389. Moonus Mandel
  390. Mulita
  391. Munt Ontdal (astronomical object)
  392. Mustafar
  393. Mykapo system
  394. N'Zoth
  395. Naalol
  396. Naboo
  397. Nadiri
  398. Nadiri Dockyards
  399. Nag Ubdur
  400. Nakadia
  401. Nal Hutta
  402. Nantoon
  403. Nar Shaddaa
  404. Narthex
  405. Necropolis
  406. Neijaia
  407. Neskar
  408. Nevarro
  409. Nexus Ortai
  410. Nightside
  411. Nithorni
  412. Nixus
  413. Nkllon
  414. Noctu
  415. Nothoiin
  416. Novka
  417. OR-Kappa-2722
  418. Oba Diah moon
  419. Obroa-skai
  420. Odona
  421. Odynnia Gavo
  422. Omereth
  423. Onderon
  424. Ontotho
  425. Oon
  426. Oosalon
  427. Ord Mantell
  428. Ord Trasi
  429. Orish
  430. Orto
  431. Oru
  432. Oseon
  433. Oseon system/Canon
  434. Osisis Station
  435. Osseriton
  436. Ossus
  437. Ost Molkar
  438. Otomok system
  439. Otor's Hub
  440. Oulanne
  441. Ovanis
  442. Ozri II
  443. Pacara
  444. Pagodon
  445. Pam'ba
  446. Pamarthe
  447. Pammant
  448. Panna
  449. Pantolomin
  450. Parnassos
  451. Pasaana
  452. Pasher
  453. Patrolia
  454. Pesfavri
  455. Phatrong
  456. Pheryon
  457. Phorsa Gedd
  458. Pillio
  459. Pipada
  460. Planet X
  461. Plexis
  462. Ploo
  463. Polaar
  464. Polis Massa
  465. Polyneus
  466. Ponemah Terminal
  467. Pormthulis system
  468. Praxat Sil
  469. Pressylla system
  470. Primea
  471. Protobranch
  472. Pyra
  473. Pzandias
  474. Qlint
  475. Quantxi
  476. Quarmendy
  477. Quarzite
  478. Quilken
  479. Raada
  480. Raithal
  481. Rajtiri
  482. Rakata Prime
  483. Ralltiir
  484. Ramitrix
  485. Randon
  486. Rapacc
  487. Rarlech system
  488. Rattatak
  489. Raysho
  490. Recluse's Nebula
  491. Red Nebula
  492. Redhurne system
  493. Refnu
  494. Rentaxius VIII
  495. Rentor
  496. Retta
  497. Ridlay
  498. Rina Major
  499. Ringali Nebula
  500. Ringlite system
  501. Rinn
  502. Riosa
  503. Rishi Moon
  504. Risso hot springs moon
  505. Ro-Loo Triangle
  506. Rodia
  507. Rohm
  508. Rothana
  509. Rothana Imperial Shipyards
  510. Ruuria
  511. Ryarten
  512. Ryloth
  513. Rystan
  514. Safrifa
  515. Sag Kemper
  516. Sakreen
  517. Salient system
  518. Salliche
  519. Sarka
  520. Scarif
  521. Scipio
  522. Sedri
  523. Sedri Minor
  524. Seelos
  525. Seelos system
  526. Sembla
  527. Serelia
  528. Serenno
  529. Sergia
  530. Sesid
  531. Sevarcos
  532. Shadda-Bi-Boran
  533. Sharb
  534. Shattered Moon
  535. Shili
  536. Shu-Torun
  537. Shulstine
  538. Shuraden
  539. Sibensko
  540. Sivad
  541. Skaradosh
  542. Skuhl
  543. Skye
  544. Sneeve
  545. Socorro
  546. Solarine
  547. Son-tuul
  548. Spalex
  549. Sposia
  550. StarCave Nebula
  551. Starlight Beacon
  552. Station Theta Black
  553. Stewjon
  554. Stivic
  555. Stobar
  556. Strokill Prime
  557. Stygeon Prime
  558. Substation Grimdock
  559. Sullust
  560. Sunrise
  561. Sunspot Prison
  562. Suntilla
  563. Tah'Nuhna
  564. Tais Brabbo
  565. Takobo
  566. Takodana
  567. Tamsye Prime
  568. Tangenine
  569. Tansyl 5
  570. Taris
  571. Tarsunt (planet)
  572. Tarsunt system
  573. Taul
  574. Taw Provode
  575. Taw Provode's solitary moon
  576. Taz Molkar
  577. Telerath
  578. Tempes
  579. Terminus
  580. Teth
  581. Tevel
  582. Thannt
  583. The Wheel
  584. Thearterra
  585. Thelj
  586. Thiafeña
  587. Thrad
  588. Thune
  589. Tiikae
  590. Tirahnn
  591. Titan
  592. Togoria system
  593. Toledian
  594. Tomark
  595. Toola
  596. Toprawa
  597. Torost
  598. Triffis
  599. Trillia
  600. Tristall
  601. Troiken
  602. Troithe
  603. Trymant III
  604. Trymant IV
  605. Tsevuka
  606. Tund
  607. Turco Prime
  608. Turkana
  609. Tynna
  610. Typhonic Nebula
  611. Tython
  612. Uba IV
  613. Ubardia
  614. Ultaar
  615. Unidentified Chiss colony world
  616. Unidentified Mid Rim star
  617. Unidentified astronomical object (Millennium Falcon)
  618. Unidentified astronomical object (neural core)
  619. Unidentified desert planet
  620. Unidentified moon (Ochi)
  621. Unidentified moon (Tribunal)
  622. Unidentified ocean planet
  623. Unidentified orbiting merchant-hub station
  624. Unidentified planet (Bylsma)
  625. Unidentified planet (Eeth Koth)
  626. Unidentified planet (Han Solo)
  627. Unidentified planet (Magna Tolvan)
  628. Unidentified planet (droid uprising)
  629. Unidentified rocky planet
  630. Unidentified star (Byrnum Maw)
  631. Unidentified star (Starkiller Base)
  632. Unidentified uninhabited refuge world
  633. Unox
  634. Unzel
  635. Uquine
  636. Urajab
  637. Uro
  638. Ushruu
  639. Utapau
  640. Utegetu Nebula
  641. Uvena Prime
  642. Uyter
  643. Vaced
  644. Vagadarr system
  645. Vallt
  646. Valo
  647. Valron
  648. Vandelhelm
  649. Vandor
  650. Vargos 9
  651. Vassek
  652. Velmor
  653. Velusia
  654. Vendaxa
  655. Vespaara
  656. Vetine
  657. Vinsoth
  658. Vint
  659. Virkoi
  660. Vodran
  661. Vorlag
  662. Vrant Tarnum
  663. Vrogas Vas
  664. Vulpinus Nebula
  665. Vyndal
  666. Wadi Raffa
  667. Warlentta
  668. Warlentta system
  669. Wayward Comet
  670. Wecacoe
  671. Wellspring of Life
  672. Werma Lesser
  673. Wevo
  674. Winsit
  675. Wobani
  676. Wrea
  677. Wynkahthu
  678. X3-299-11
  679. Xais
  680. Y'Toub System
  681. Yaga Minor
  682. Yalbec Prime
  683. Yarma system
  684. Yavin 4
  685. Yeksom
  686. Yotch
  687. Yoturba
  688. Zardossa Stix
  689. Zastiga
  690. Zavian Abyss
  691. Zeffo
  692. Zeffo system
  693. Zeitooine
  694. Zeltros