[15:21] <Graestan> Here begins the meeting proper.
[15:21] <Toprawa> Can we kill some articles now? XD
[15:21] <Toprawa> Yes
[15:21] <Graestan> Tope, would you like to share links?
[15:21] <Graestan> Or shall I?
[15:21] <Toprawa> Um.
[15:21] <ChackJadson> Hey one thing real quick. If I'm not reviewing a ton, I apologize; it's probably 'cause I'm very active on the FAN page (Inqing)
[15:21] <Toprawa> One second.
[15:21] <Toprawa> ...
[15:21] <ChackJadson> So, sorry if I'm not reviewing as much as some others occasionally
[15:21] <Graestan> It's cool, Chack. You're fine.
[15:22] <ChackJadson> Cool, cool. Anyway, let's begin when Tope's ready
[15:22] <GrandMoffTranner> Come on, I have an itchy trigger finger.
[15:22] <Toprawa> ugh
[15:22] <Graestan> First article: http://starwars.wikia.com/index.php?title=Battle_of_Balmorra_(Second_Galactic_Civil_War)&oldid=2306538
[15:22] <Graestan> No change since the last meeting.
[15:22] -->| Ralltiir has joined #wookieepedia-agricorps
[15:22] =-= Mode #wookieepedia-agricorps +o Ralltiir by chanserv
[15:22] <Ralltiir> ok
[15:22] <GrandMoffTranner> Kill.
[15:22] <Ralltiir> I can link now
[15:22] <Ralltiir> Kill
[15:22] <CavalierOne> Kill
[15:22] <Cylka> kill
[15:22] <ChackJadson> Kill
[15:22] <Graestan> Death to Balmorra
[15:23] <Graestan> Next up, the slovenly http://starwars.wikia.com/index.php?title=Duel_in_the_Chancellor%27s_Office&diff=2344533&oldid=2306546
[15:23] <ChackJadson> Kill
[15:23] <GrandMoffTranner> Kill.
[15:23] <Graestan> A mess forever, regardless of changes. Kill.
[15:23] <Ralltiir> I'm not linking now?
[15:23] <ChackJadson> Like Mace Windu
[15:23] <Ralltiir> Kill
[15:23] <CavalierOne> Kill
[15:23] <Cylka> kill
[15:23] <Graestan> (link the ones to probe, I'll handle the old ones)
[15:23] <Toprawa> ok
[15:24] <Graestan> Death to the Chancellor.
[15:24] <Graestan> And now, its ugly partner: http://starwars.wikia.com/index.php?title=Duel_in_the_Senate_(Great_Jedi_Purge)&oldid=2306547
[15:24] <CavalierOne> Its treason then?
[15:24] <GrandMoffTranner> Kill.
[15:24] <Toprawa> Kill
[15:24] <Graestan> No change.
[15:24] <CavalierOne> Kill
[15:24] <Graestan> Kill!
[15:24] <Cylka> kill
[15:24] <ChackJadson> kill
[15:24] <Graestan> Cylka, I see you already have a taste for killing.
[15:25] <Graestan> And here: http://starwars.wikia.com/index.php?title=Duel_on_Roqoo_Depot&diff=2307391&oldid=2306548
[15:25] <Cylka> I learned from the best :-P
[15:25] <Toprawa> if someone would have created a BTS for this, I would keep
[15:25] <Toprawa> that's all it really needs
[15:25] <Graestan> Naru fixed the infobox sourcing.
[15:25] <GrandMoffTranner> Needs the references from the intro removed.
[15:25] <ChackJadson> I'll do it, Tope
[15:25] <Toprawa> Keep on Chack's condition, then
[15:25] <Toprawa> and yes, remove intro sourcing
[15:25] <ChackJadson> I'll do that too, GMT
[15:25] <CavalierOne> Ditto
[15:25] <Graestan> Keep per Toprawa.
[15:25] <GrandMoffTranner> Keep.
[15:26] <Cylka> per Tope
[15:26] <ChackJadson> so keep
[15:26] <Graestan> Clemency? We are weaklings!
[15:26] <Toprawa> heh
[15:26] <Graestan> But Mandos aren't: http://starwars.wikia.com/index.php?title=Mandalorian_Wars&diff=2334057&oldid=2306551
[15:26] <Toprawa> I blame myself :P
[15:26] <Toprawa> This article is an FA for half-way through
[15:26] <Toprawa> Then it becomes shite
[15:26] <Toprawa> Kill
[15:26] <Graestan> Very little change.
[15:26] <GrandMoffTranner> Kill the shite.
[15:26] <Graestan> Also part of Sentry's troll festival of the moment.
[15:26] <Graestan> Kill.
[15:26] <ChackJadson> kill
[15:26] <Cylka> Needs a lot of work. Kill it.
[15:26] <CavalierOne> Kill
[15:27] <Graestan> The buck stops here.
[15:27] <Graestan> Now: http://starwars.wikia.com/index.php?title=Massacre_at_Ossus&diff=2342609&oldid=2306550
[15:27] <Toprawa> looks decent...
[15:27] <Graestan> Grunny fixed the sourcing.
[15:27] <GrandMoffTranner> {{Fact}} tag in BTS, though.
[15:27] <Toprawa> oh wait
[15:27] <Toprawa> yes, per Tranner
[15:28] <Graestan> The last fact tag is erroneous.
[15:28] <Toprawa> Is it?
[15:28] <Graestan> It is a self-sourcing statement.
[15:28] <Toprawa> ok
[15:28] <GrandMoffTranner> Right.
[15:28] <Graestan> I say keep.
[15:28] <Toprawa> Well...
[15:28] <Toprawa> Keep
[15:28] <GrandMoffTranner> Keep.
[15:28] <Cylka> Keep.
[15:28] <CavalierOne> Keep
[15:29] <ChackJadson> keep
[15:29] <Toprawa> heh, this next one is a doozy
[15:29] <Graestan> And now it is time to lay this here ugly list to rest: http://starwars.wikia.com/index.php?title=New_Sith_Wars&diff=2324867&oldid=2306555
[15:29] <GrandMoffTranner> Kill.
[15:29] <Graestan> Kill it with fire.
[15:29] <Toprawa> Kill with fire
[15:29] <Toprawa> haha
[15:29] <ChackJadson> kill
[15:29] <Cylka> Kill
[15:30] <Graestan> It dies.
[15:30] <Graestan> Naru appears to have been busy: http://starwars.wikia.com/index.php?title=Operation%3A_Knightfall&diff=2341978&oldid=2306556
[15:30] <CavalierOne> Fire it with kill
[15:30] <Graestan> What is wrong?
[15:30] <Toprawa> yeah, I helped Naru get this one to meet MOS
[15:30] <GrandMoffTranner> Ref in intro, and there are far more sources out there.
[15:30] <Toprawa> It looks ok, but I haven't read through
[15:30] <Graestan> http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Wookieepedia:AC/Operation:_Knightfall
[15:30] <ChackJadson> It's looks better, but is it enough?
[15:30] <Toprawa> right, per Chac
[15:30] <Toprawa> k
[15:30] <Cylka> I just looked at it. It needs a bit of work with the sourcing.
[15:31] <Toprawa> does it meet "broad coverage" requirement?
[15:31] <ChackJadson> The intro is terrible, BTW. It has sourcing and is bascially just a list of possible names for it
[15:31] <ChackJadson> But that's minor
[15:31] <Toprawa> there do appear to be a number of unreferences Sources
[15:31] <Toprawa> the BTS sucks too
[15:31] <GrandMoffTranner> Needs more work.
[15:31] <Toprawa> unreferenced*
[15:31] <ChackJadson> I'm leaning towards kill
[15:32] <Cylka> Intro doesn't match the article.
[15:32] <Toprawa> I am, despite a good effort by Naru
[15:32] <GrandMoffTranner> I say kill.
[15:32] <CavalierOne> Same
[15:32] <Graestan> Kill for now. I am sure Naru can work it back up to spec, it's getting there.
[15:32] <Toprawa> Kill
[15:32] <ChackJadson> Kill FTW!
[15:32] <Cylka> Needs too much work. Kill
[15:33] <Graestan> I tell you it dead.
[15:33] <Graestan> http://starwars.wikia.com/index.php?title=Skirmish_at_Carkoon&diff=2336961&oldid=2306557
[15:33] <Graestan> Kill this monstrosity.
[15:33] <ChackJadson> Kill
[15:33] <Toprawa> convince me to keep it, Chack :P
[15:33] <ChackJadson> And yes, it's mine. But it's poor
[15:33] <GrandMoffTranner> Kill.
[15:33] <Cylka> Kill
[15:33] <ChackJadson> I gave up on it :(
[15:33] <Toprawa> the Sources list needs a lot more, I'd imagine
[15:33] <Toprawa> I can't believe this isn't referenced in everything...ever :P
[15:33] <Toprawa> Kill
[15:34] <CavalierOne> Kill
[15:34] <Graestan> Boom da gasser, den crashin da boss's heyblibber, den killed!
[15:34] <Graestan> http://starwars.wikia.com/index.php?title=Combined_Clans_Center_Building&oldid=2306558
[15:34] <Graestan> No change. Kill.
[15:34] <ChackJadson> Kill
[15:34] <GrandMoffTranner> Kill.
[15:34] <Toprawa> is this the sub-250 word one?
[15:34] <GrandMoffTranner> Yep.
[15:35] <Toprawa> Kill
[15:35] <Cylka> Kill.
[15:35] <CavalierOne> Kill
[15:35] <Graestan> I hate Bothans anyway.
[15:35] <Graestan> http://starwars.wikia.com/index.php?title=Exovar%27s_Emporium&diff=2310206&oldid=2306560
[15:35] <Graestan> Gonk fixed it up a bit.
[15:35] <GrandMoffTranner> Looks good enough to keep.
[15:36] <ChackJadson> Keep
[15:36] <Toprawa> doesn't really meet LG if we were to assume that location articles are to meet something akin to planet LG standards
[15:36] <Toprawa> I dislike when we have random section titles
[15:36] <Toprawa> But that could be cleaned up
[15:36] <CavalierOne> Keep
[15:36] <Graestan> I'd say it falls under GA okayness as is, now. Keep.
[15:36] <Cylka> Keep
[15:37] <Graestan> If it were FA, though. ROAR!
[15:37] <Graestan> Tope?
[15:37] <Toprawa> Ugh, I reluctantly keep, I guess. I think I'm going to work with this one
[15:37] <Graestan> It's a kept article. Gonk wouldn't mind helping, I bet.
[15:37] <Toprawa> Just section it more per the LG
[15:37] <Graestan> http://starwars.wikia.com/index.php?title=Fondor&diff=2333050&oldid=2306561
[15:37] <Graestan> Very little change.
[15:37] <GrandMoffTranner> Kill.
[15:37] <Toprawa> Destroy that planet
[15:37] <ChackJadson> Kill
[15:38] <Graestan> I say let the Vong invade.
[15:38] <Cylka> Kill
[15:38] <CavalierOne> Kill
[15:38] <Graestan> Killt.
[15:38] <Graestan> http://starwars.wikia.com/index.php?title=Korriban&diff=2318110&oldid=2306563
[15:38] <Graestan> Greatest lead quote evar.
[15:38] <GrandMoffTranner> Kill.
[15:39] <Graestan> But still a shite article. Kill.
[15:39] <ChackJadson> Nuke
[15:39] <Toprawa> Jehoshaphat system?
[15:39] <Toprawa> Kill
[15:39] <Cylka> Korriban scares me. It needs to die.
[15:39] <CavalierOne> killilty kill
[15:39] <Graestan> Another shithole of a planet that it appears someone vandalized. http://starwars.wikia.com/index.php?title=Ryloth&diff=2318118&oldid=2306564
[15:40] <GrandMoffTranner> Kill.
[15:40] * Graestan storms off to see who removed the tag and ban them
[15:40] <ChackJadson> Destroy
[15:40] <Toprawa> I love the non-sourcing.
[15:40] <Toprawa> Kill
[15:40] <Cylka> Kill
[15:40] <Graestan> Ban accomplished. Now we can kill the article.
[15:41] <CavalierOne> Have to step out for a short while - kill this and Cloak. Accept majority on the other three. Probe all character articles discussed until I get back.
[15:41] <Graestan> Very well.
[15:42] <Toprawa> Graestan vote?
[15:42] <Graestan> Kill!
[15:43] <Toprawa> I wonder what would happen if we killed an article that's current a FAN? :P
[15:44] <ChackJadson> XD
[15:44] <Graestan> The perennial favorite: http://starwars.wikia.com/index.php?title=Taris&diff=2324782&oldid=2306566
[15:44] <Toprawa> currently*
[15:44] <Cylka> It's missing a lot of infromation.
[15:44] <GrandMoffTranner> Kill.
[15:44] <Graestan> Base Delta Zero it.
[15:44] <Cylka> Kill it.
[15:44] <Toprawa> Kill
[15:44] <ChackJadson> Kill
[15:44] <Cylka> I'll work on it eventually.
[15:44] <Graestan> Effectively sterilized with turbolaser fire.
[15:45] <Graestan> http://starwars.wikia.com/index.php?title=Taris_dueling_ring&diff=2307705&oldid=2306565
[15:45] <Graestan> Fiolli fixed it.
[15:45] <Graestan> Keep.
[15:45] <GrandMoffTranner> Keep.
[15:45] <Cylka> Keep.
[15:45] <Toprawa> Keepity keep
[15:45] <Toprawa> this is how I want to see Exovar's laid out, btw
[15:45] <ChackJadson> Keep
[15:46] <Graestan> Keepded.
[15:46] <Graestan> Now for Cylka's Opus: http://starwars.wikia.com/index.php?title=Telos_IV&diff=2341598&oldid=2306567
[15:46] <Graestan> I say keep.
[15:46] <GrandMoffTranner> Keep.
[15:46] <Graestan> I looked at it long and hard.
[15:46] <Toprawa> Are we /allowed/ to kill FANs? :P
[15:46] <Toprawa> Keep
[15:46] <Graestan> Yeah, they have no status.
[15:46] <Cylka> Keep.
[15:47] <Ralltiir> do I get to vote too?
[15:47] <ChackJadson> No :P
[15:47] <Graestan> Probably.
[15:47] <Ralltiir> I vote kill too
[15:47] <Cylka> :-P
[15:47] <Graestan> You're in the minority, Ralltiir lad.
[15:47] <Graestan> [Redacted by administration]
[15:47] <Toprawa> [Redacted by administration]
[15:48] <Graestan> http://starwars.wikia.com/index.php?title=Cloak_of_Deception&diff=2324800&oldid=2306568
[15:48] <Graestan> Great book, bad article. Kill.
[15:48] <GrandMoffTranner> Kill!
[15:48] <ChackJadson> Falcon Punch it
[15:48] <ChackJadson> That means kill :P
[15:48] <Cylka> Kill.
[15:49] <Toprawa> Kill, though I wish we had an OOU format for the MOS.
[15:49] <Graestan> "It was set to stun, I swear!"
[15:49] <Toprawa> Besides the "Appearances" list
[15:49] <Ralltiir> oh, am I linking now?
[15:50] <Graestan> Your turn, Carl from "Sling Blade."
[15:50] <Ralltiir> Ok, sports fans.
[15:50] * Graestan eats some French-fried puhtaters
[15:50] <GrandMoffTranner> Okay, I have to go. My notes are on the meeting page.
[15:50] <ChackJadson> See ya
[15:50] <Graestan> Bye Tranner.
[15:50] <Ralltiir> Now we decide whether to probe these articles for kill-review next meeting.
[15:50] <--| GrandMoffTranner has left #wookieepedia-agricorps
[15:50] <Cylka> Bye
[15:50] <Ralltiir> http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Hermione_Bagwa
[15:51] <Ralltiir> Unsourced infobox and biography items. No P/T. Everything just seems a little skimpy, especially the BTS. Probably not a huge fix, but it would definitely benefit from someone taking the time to improve this one.
[15:51] <ChackJadson> Kill this
[15:51] <ChackJadson> Well, probe
[15:51] <Ralltiir> Probe.
[15:51] <Graestan> Probe and replace with the Hermione Granger article from HPW.
[15:51] <Cylka> Probe.
[15:52] <Ralltiir> Probed.
[15:52] <Ralltiir> http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Sio_Bibble
[15:52] <Ralltiir> 4dot fixed this, and it's currently an FAN
[15:52] <Graestan> Leave it, no bother killing.
[15:52] <Ralltiir> Keep
[15:52] <ChackJadson> Keep
[15:52] <Cylka> Keep
[15:52] <Graestan> His beard has a reservoir tip. :S
[15:53] <Ralltiir> Kept
[15:53] <Ralltiir> http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Depa_Billaba
[15:53] <Ralltiir> No sourcing at all
[15:53] <Graestan> Bibble looks like Socrates from Bill and Ted:http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/File:Bibblemourning.JPG
[15:53] <ChackJadson> Probe
[15:53] <Graestan> [Redacted by administration]
[15:53] <Ralltiir> Probe
[15:53] <Cylka> Probe.
[15:53] <Ralltiir> Probed
[15:53] <Ralltiir> http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Buboicullaar
[15:54] <Ralltiir> Unsourced ref links, was Acky's article, who admits expansion is needed
[15:54] <ChackJadson> Probe
[15:54] <Graestan> Probe per Acky the Man Himself.
[15:54] <Cylka> Probe.
[15:54] <Ralltiir> Probe
[15:54] <Ralltiir> Article probed.
[15:54] <Ralltiir> http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Xandel_Carivus
[15:55] <Ralltiir> Xandel Carivus - Unsourced infobox and succession box. Should be easy enough for someone knowledgeable
[15:55] <Graestan> Probe. Terrible article layout.
[15:55] <ChackJadson> Probe
[15:55] <Cylka> Probe.
[15:55] <Graestan> No P&T
[15:55] <Graestan> No BtS
[15:55] <Ralltiir> Probe
[15:55] <Ralltiir> Article probed.
[15:56] <Ralltiir> http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Jorus_C%27baoth
[15:56] <Ralltiir> My page comments:
[15:56] <Ralltiir> - I think this article does well to exemplify what a "broad-coverage GA" should be. Over 1,000 words, but not enough detail to be an FA. Still, some very minor infobox sourcing issues, and it should have a Powers and Abilities section.
[15:56] <Graestan> Probe Moses.
[15:56] <ChackJadson> Probe
[15:56] <Cylka> Probe.
[15:56] <Ralltiir> Probe
[15:56] <Ralltiir> Article probed.
[15:56] <ChackJadson> I should FA him, to go with Joruus :P
[15:57] <Ralltiir> http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Chaf%27orm%27bintrano
[15:57] <Ralltiir> Needs a P/T
[15:57] <ChackJadson> Probe
[15:57] <Cylka> Probe.
[15:57] <Graestan> Formbi deserves a P&T and a real BtS. Probe.
[15:57] <Ralltiir> unsourced infobox
[15:57] <Ralltiir> Probe.
[15:57] <Ralltiir> Article probed.
[15:57] <Ralltiir> http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Kaleb_Darme
[15:57] <Ralltiir> no P/T or BTS
[15:58] <Ralltiir> who does he look like?
[15:58] <Ralltiir> he reminds me of an actor or something
[15:58] <Graestan> Probe.
[15:58] <Graestan> Charlie Sheen.
[15:58] <Ralltiir> Kind of
[15:58] <Cylka> Probe
[15:58] <ChackJadson> Probe him
[15:58] <Ralltiir> Probed.
[15:58] <Graestan> He's also apparently dastardly: http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/File:KalebDarme-KellaRand-SWAJ6.png
[15:58] <Ralltiir> http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Samhan_Dobo
[15:58] <Graestan> You skipped Choi?
[15:59] <Ralltiir> did I?
[15:59] <ChackJadson> yeah
[15:59] <Ralltiir> ok
[15:59] <Ralltiir> rewind
[15:59] <Ralltiir> http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Tsui_Choi
[15:59] <Graestan> Give Choi a P&A. Probe.
[15:59] <ChackJadson> Probe. No improvement
[15:59] <Ralltiir> Infobox and article sourcing issues. Could use a P/A, I assume
[15:59] <Cylka> Probe.
[15:59] <Ralltiir> Probe.
[15:59] <Ralltiir> Article probed.
[15:59] <Graestan> Definitely aP&A, he was a good Jedi.
[15:59] <Ralltiir> http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Samhan_Dobo
[15:59] <Ralltiir> Article had unique intro info.
[15:59] <Ralltiir> Apparently fixed?
[16:00] <Cylka> Goodwood fixed it.
[16:00] === #Wookieepedia http://starwars.wikia.com
[16:00] <Ralltiir> Keep
[16:00] <Ralltiir> No probe
[16:00] <Cylka> Keep.
[16:00] =-= CavalierOne was booted from #wookieepedia-agricorps by YOU (Graestan)
[16:00] <Ralltiir> but why?!
[16:00] <Graestan> No probe.
[16:00] <Graestan> I hate those Dobos.
[16:01] === You have invited CavalierTwo to #wookieepedia-agricorps.
[16:01] <ChackJadson> keep
[16:01] -->| CavalierTwo has joined #wookieepedia-agricorps
[16:01] <Ralltiir> Article not probed.
[16:01] <Ralltiir> CavalierTWO
[16:01] <Ralltiir> *Holy* crap
[16:01] <Ralltiir> Next up
[16:01] <Ralltiir> http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Daultay_Dofine
[16:01] <Graestan> He just wasn't cavalier enough.
[16:01] <Ralltiir> 4dot definitely fixed this.
[16:02] <ChackJadson> keep, silly
[16:02] <Ralltiir> I want to review it.
[16:02] <Graestan> Keep Dofine. The absentees say keep, too.
[16:02] <ChackJadson> I just read it. It's excellent, IMO
[16:02] <Ralltiir> Keep
[16:02] <CavalierTwo> Keep.
[16:02] <Cylka> No probe. Keep.
[16:02] <Ralltiir> Article kept.
[16:02] <Ralltiir> http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Dorsk_81
[16:02] <Ralltiir> Weak sourcing
[16:02] <ChackJadson> Probe
[16:02] <Graestan> Fourdot removed the GAcleanup.
[16:02] <Graestan> :|
[16:02] <Ralltiir> heh
[16:03] <Ralltiir> We shall...speak..with him :P
[16:03] <Graestan> I will.
[16:03] <Graestan> Probe Dorsk.
[16:03] =-= Mode #wookieepedia-agricorps +o CavalierTwo by Graestan
[16:03] <Ralltiir> that is the worst infobox picture ever, by the way
[16:03] <CavalierTwo> Probe
[16:03] <Ralltiir> Probe
[16:03] <Cylka> Probe.
[16:03] <Ralltiir> someone apparently removed the tag on that one too
[16:03] <Ralltiir> no wait
[16:03] <ChackJadson> No, just wasn't added, I think
[16:04] <Ralltiir> there was no tag.
[16:04] <Ralltiir> because it wasn't probed
[16:04] <Graestan> hahaha
[16:04] <Graestan> Whoops.
[16:04] <Ralltiir> haha
[16:04] <Graestan> Good thing I never jumped the gun. :S
[16:04] <Ralltiir> http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Durrei
[16:04] <ChackJadson> Probe quickly
[16:04] <Graestan> You skipped Durane.
[16:04] <Ralltiir> God damnit
[16:04] <Ralltiir> http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Giles_Durane
[16:05] <Graestan> No sourcing on Durane. Probe.
[16:05] <CavalierTwo> probe
[16:05] <Ralltiir> No sourcing
[16:05] <Cylka> Probe.
[16:05] <ChackJadson> Probe
[16:05] <Ralltiir> Probe
[16:05] <Ralltiir> Care to convince us otherwise, Cav?
[16:05] <Ralltiir> :P
[16:05] <Ralltiir> Article probed.
[16:06] <Ralltiir> http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Durrei
[16:06] <Graestan> Probe Durrei. No P&A or BtS.
[16:06] <CavalierTwo> Why would I? Not my article :P
[16:06] <ChackJadson> Probation for the sucker
[16:06] <CavalierTwo> Probe
[16:06] <Ralltiir> Just a formality :P
[16:06] <Cylka> Really skimpy. Probe.
[16:06] <Ralltiir> Probe
[16:06] <Ralltiir> Article probed.
[16:06] <Ralltiir> http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Energizer_Bunny
[16:06] <Ralltiir> This one hurts my soul
[16:06] <Cylka> I never understood this article.
[16:06] <ChackJadson> Probe
[16:07] <Ralltiir> Some really poor speculation and OR. Serious MOS issues.
[16:07] <Graestan> Bad joke article. Probe.
[16:07] <Cylka> Probe.
[16:07] <Ralltiir> it was an old commercial from like 1994 or something
[16:07] <Ralltiir> I probably would have deleted it on sight as a new creation
[16:07] <Ralltiir> Probe
[16:07] <Graestan> [Redacted by administration]
[16:07] <CavalierTwo> Probe.
[16:07] <Ralltiir> Article probed.
[16:07] <Ralltiir> http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/The_Envoy
[16:07] <Ralltiir> No sourcing. The BTS claims that it is unclear whether she's a Jedi, but the entire article treats her as one. Not so good.
[16:08] <ChackJadson> Probe
[16:08] <Ralltiir> (My meeting comments)
[16:08] <Graestan> [Redacted by administration]
[16:08] <Ralltiir> well, duh
[16:08] <Graestan> [Redacted by administration]
[16:08] <Graestan> [Redacted by administration]
[16:08] <CavalierTwo> [Redacted by administration]
[16:09] <Ralltiir> Probe
[16:09] <Cylka> Probe.
[16:09] <CavalierTwo> Probe
[16:09] <Ralltiir> Article probed.
[16:09] <Ralltiir> http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Valenthyne_Farfalla
[16:09] <Ralltiir> Unsourced infobox, paragraph in the bio, succession box. No P/A section.
[16:09] <ChackJadson> Probe
[16:09] <Cylka> Probe.
[16:10] <CavalierTwo> Probe
[16:10] <Ralltiir> Probe
[16:10] <Ralltiir> Graestan?
[16:10] <Graestan> Hang on....
[16:11] <Ralltiir> Stay on target...
[16:11] <Graestan> This is an obnoxious article about how people hapy DK.
[16:11] <Graestan> hate*
[16:11] <Graestan> Probe it.
[16:11] <Ralltiir> Donkey Kong?
[16:11] <Ralltiir> Article probed.
[16:11] <Ralltiir> http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Melvin_Fett
[16:11] <ChackJadson> Probe. No refs
[16:11] <Ralltiir> Unnecessary speculative bits that should be cleaned up.
[16:11] <Cylka> No sourcing. Probe
[16:12] <CavalierTwo> Probe
[16:12] <Ralltiir> Probe
[16:12] <Ralltiir> The sourcing isn't a huge issue, but it's that we're sourcing a speculative statement
[16:12] <Ralltiir> which makes no sense
[16:12] <Ralltiir> otherwise, the sourcing is unnecessary
[16:12] <Graestan> Probe. Not a hard fix.
[16:13] <Ralltiir> Article probed.
[16:13] <Ralltiir> http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Herrit
[16:13] <Ralltiir> no P/T
[16:13] <ChackJadson> Probe
[16:13] <Cylka> probe.
[16:13] <Graestan> Probe.
[16:13] <Ralltiir> Probe
[16:13] <CavalierTwo> Probe
[16:13] <Ralltiir> Article probed.
[16:14] <Ralltiir> http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Irek_Ismaren
[16:14] <ChackJadson> Probe
[16:14] <Ralltiir> Lots of relics of a bygone era of article quality. No infobox sourcing, unlinked references, no P/T, no BTS.
[16:14] <CavalierTwo> Probe
[16:14] <Graestan> You skipped one again
[16:14] <Ralltiir> we'll come back to it :P
[16:14] <ChackJadson> lol
[16:14] <Graestan> Probe Ismaren.
[16:14] <Ralltiir> This is what you get for using IE
[16:14] <Ralltiir> Probe Ismaren
[16:14] <Graestan> Ismaren could be an FA easily.
[16:14] <Ralltiir> Yeah
[16:15] <Cylka> Ismaren - Probe.
[16:15] <Ralltiir> Article probed.
[16:15] <Ralltiir> Backtracking...
[16:15] <Ralltiir> http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Tresk_Im%27nel
[16:15] <Ralltiir> no P/T or BTS
[16:15] <Graestan> PROBE
[16:15] <CavalierTwo> Probe
[16:15] <ChackJadson> Probe
[16:15] <Cylka> Probe.
[16:16] <Ralltiir> Probe
[16:16] <Ralltiir> Article probed.
[16:16] <Ralltiir> http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Shimrra_Jamaane
[16:16] <Graestan> Shimrra's glittering eyes qualify for Dumbest Shit Ever in the EU
[16:16] <Graestan> Probe.
[16:16] <Ralltiir> Apparently DC worked on this one, but Chack wanted to discuss it
[16:16] <ChackJadson> I'd say probe.
[16:16] <Graestan> He deserves a P&A, too.
[16:16] <CavalierTwo> Me too
[16:16] <ChackJadson> Yeah, I think it could be a /lot/ more comprehensive, even for GA
[16:16] <Ralltiir> I would abstain only because I don't know, and it appears to meet broad coverage, but on Chack's word I probe
[16:17] <ChackJadson> I am honored
[16:17] <Ralltiir> heh
[16:17] <Ralltiir> Cylka? Care to lawyer this one?
[16:17] <Graestan> She's mesmerized by his glowing eyes.
[16:18] <Ralltiir> Article probed then.
[16:18] <Ralltiir> Next up
[16:18] <Ralltiir> http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Jin-Jin
[16:18] <Cylka> I'm not sure.
[16:18] <Ralltiir> no BTS, but handled
[16:18] <Ralltiir> as in, now a BTS
[16:18] <Graestan> Keep Jin-Jin per DC's addition.
[16:18] <Ralltiir> Keep
[16:18] <CavalierTwo> Keep
[16:18] <ChackJadson> keep
[16:19] <Cylka> Keep
[16:19] <Ralltiir> Article not probed.
[16:19] <Ralltiir> http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/K%27Kruhk
[16:19] <Ralltiir> serious sourcing issues
[16:19] <Graestan> Probe him AND his hat.
[16:19] <Ralltiir> haha
[16:19] <ChackJadson> What, specifically, Tope?
[16:19] <Ralltiir> Look through it
[16:19] <CavalierTwo> Probe him. Leave the hat alone.
[16:19] <Ralltiir> Whole sections are unsourced
[16:19] <Ralltiir> Probe
[16:20] <ChackJadson> Ok. Oh, I see. Probe
[16:20] <Ralltiir> Cylka?
[16:20] <Cylka> Probe
[16:20] <Ralltiir> Article probed.
[16:20] <Ralltiir> http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Obi-Wan_Kenobi_impersonator
[16:20] <ChackJadson> Probe
[16:20] <Ralltiir> No sourcing, P/T, or BTS
[16:21] <Ralltiir> he could even have a P/A, in a sense
[16:21] <Cylka> Probe
[16:21] <Ralltiir> not a Force-user, but wields faux Force powers
[16:21] <Graestan> Neat article, but probe per lacking sections.
[16:21] <CavalierTwo> Probe
[16:21] <Ralltiir> it's a cool CSW story
[16:21] <Ralltiir> I would even rewrite this
[16:21] <Ralltiir> but Probe
[16:21] <Ralltiir> Article probed.
[16:21] <Ralltiir> last one
[16:21] <Ralltiir> special addition to agenda
[16:21] <Ralltiir> http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Hoth_%28comic%29
[16:22] <ChackJadson> Just skip to kill :P
[16:22] <Ralltiir> I wish we could.
[16:22] <Ralltiir> Probe
[16:22] <Ralltiir> not even 250 words, for starters
[16:22] <CavalierTwo> Probity probe
[16:22] <Graestan> Probe. Wish we had insta-kill.
[16:22] <Cylka> How did this end up as a GA?
[16:23] <Cylka> Probe.
[16:23] <Ralltiir> lax standards of prehistoric days
[16:23] <Graestan> I have no idea.
[16:23] <Graestan> Pre Celebration IV.
[16:23] <Ralltiir> Article probed.
[16:23] <Ralltiir> That's concludes the review.
[16:24] <Ralltiir> Graestan has the floor
[16:24] <Ralltiir> along with anyone else who wants to discuss anything
[16:24] * Graestan does the electric boogaloo
[16:24] <CavalierTwo> BTW, Grae - the timeings for UTC are still screwed up. They're an hour out for me.
[16:24] <Graestan> I yield the floor to Toprawa, who has the only discussion item.
[16:24] <Graestan> Cav: I didn't make this meeting page.
[16:24] <Graestan> I am aware of GMT and Summer Time, etc.
[16:25] <Graestan> Check the Mofference page to see if I got it right.
[16:25] <CavalierTwo> Apologies, Grae.
[16:25] <Ralltiir> I do?
[16:25] <Ralltiir> oooh yeah
[16:25] <CavalierTwo> Just thought I'd point it out.
[16:25] <Ralltiir> Ok.
[16:25] <CavalierTwo> Ralltiir: Yep. Meeting started at nine pm for me,
[16:25] <Graestan> Cav: http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/WP:M
[16:26] <Ralltiir> Cav> We'll fix it.
[16:26] <Ralltiir> We take care of our European brothers :P
[16:26] <Cylka> Meeting was at ten for me
[16:26] <Ralltiir> Discussion item 1:
[16:27] <Ralltiir> At Meeting 1, I believe it was, a discussion was held pertaining to how long a nomination should sit on the page idle, with outstanding objections, before a removal vote can be started.
[16:27] <Ralltiir> Currently, we have no policy.
[16:27] <Ralltiir> I propose making a 3-week idle policy along with a notification on the page warning users that their noms are subject to removal after this time if there are outstnading objections not handled
[16:27] <ChackJadson> 3 weeks sounds good to me
[16:27] <Ralltiir> Granted, we would allow leeway if they're still working on it
[16:27] <Graestan> I'm so glad the Inq does the beta-testing for us on shit like this.
[16:28] <CavalierTwo> Notification to the user who's nom it is should also be made.
[16:28] <Cylka> Three weeks is enough time to show up and do a little work.
[16:28] <Ralltiir> Cav> To be nice to them, that would be good, but I for one am not going to be hunting down nominators to handle my objections
[16:29] <Ralltiir> they need to look over their own nominations
[16:29] <CavalierTwo> Fair enough. I was thinking a template just to put on their talk page saying - its gone if you don't show up type of thing.
[16:29] <Ralltiir> I would leave a special note on their nomination
[16:30] <Ralltiir> That's a fair proposal, though
[16:30] <Ralltiir> Thoughts?
[16:30] <Ralltiir> To Cav's suggestion, that is
[16:30] <Cylka> Maybe a notification right before their time is up
[16:30] <Graestan> At the one-hour mark. :P
[16:31] <Cylka> But I'm not sure it should be an official policy
[16:31] <Cylka> 10 minutes left
[16:31] <ChackJadson> We done?
[16:31] <Ralltiir> as a measure of courtesy, it would be nice, but I still say they need to be active on the GAN page, which should encompass their being aware of a warning left on their nom
[16:32] <Ralltiir> I think taking it off the page is unnecessary
[16:32] <Cylka> Fair enough Tope.
[16:32] <Graestan> Cylka: 10 minutes left of what?
[16:32] <Cylka> Sorry. I'm trying to handle a couple of kids on the KOTOR page
[16:32] <Ralltiir> Until we all die, of course
[16:32] <Graestan> Hahaha
[16:33] <Ralltiir> So, 3-week length and page disclaimer approved, barring last minute objections?
[16:33] <CavalierTwo> yep
[16:33] <Ralltiir> Plus a talk page message if you're nicer than Toprawa :P
[16:33] <Cylka> Yes
[16:33] <ChackJadson> Cool
[16:33] <Ralltiir> Approved.
[16:33] <Ralltiir> Any last minute concerns?
[16:33] <Ralltiir> Chack can go, since he looks like he has to pee :P
[16:34] <ChackJadson> Nah. Just tired of sitting here :P
[16:34] <Ralltiir> And Graestan has volunteered to be the paperwork [Redacted by administration], for the record.
[16:34] <Ralltiir> [Redacted by administration]
[16:34] <Graestan> [Redacted by administration]
[16:34] <Ralltiir> That concludes AC Meeting 5.