The Great Jedi Purge List is incomplete of a few Jedi like Aidan Bok and others. I was wondering why these individuals haven't been placed on the list
Talk pages
Thanks for contributing to Wookieepedia! Before posting talk page comments, please familiarize yourself with the disclaimer at the top of talk pages, {{Talkheader}}. Talk pages are for discussion relating to changes to the article, not for a discussion about the topic in question. Thank you. CC7567 (talk) 07:06, November 23, 2009 (UTC)
Thanks for clearing that up.I am new to this.
Great Jedi Purge
No source as far as I know yet states that J'oopi Shé was killed by clone troopers. Shé could very easily have been killed in any number of ways during the rest of the Purge. Unless you can point me to a source that states he was killed by clone troopers during Order 66, then please stop adding this information. Jonjedigrandmaster (Jedi Beacon) 20:32, December 11, 2009 (UTC)
- it says in the article he was killed during Order 66 and that means he was killed by clones
- It says in the article that he was either killed during Order 66 or during the ensuing Great Jedi Purge. So he could also have been killed by Vader or any number of other Jedi hunters, not just clones. Jonjedigrandmaster (Jedi Beacon) 02:31, December 23, 2009 (UTC)
- regardless all the other entries have a cause of death so take your pick killed by jedi hunters like vader or clones
- You can't just add information that does not canonically exist. That is called Fanon, and it is not accepted here. Jonjedigrandmaster (Jedi Beacon) 02:36, December 23, 2009 (UTC)
- regardless all the other entries have a cause of death so take your pick killed by jedi hunters like vader or clones
- It says in the article that he was either killed during Order 66 or during the ensuing Great Jedi Purge. So he could also have been killed by Vader or any number of other Jedi hunters, not just clones. Jonjedigrandmaster (Jedi Beacon) 02:31, December 23, 2009 (UTC)
ok fine
Halagad Ventor
A Jedi who dies during the Purge is, by definition, not a survivor of the Purge. DD97Which bear is best? 04:40, November 16, 2010 (UTC)
Halagad never died during the Purge, he was captured by Vader and forced to give up information but he was never executed. He went into exile and was driven mad by his mistake. He eventually died after being informed that not all jedi were killed because of the Purge. He was redeemed in death. No source lists him as being killed or murdered by any jedi hunters. The year of his date of death was listed as either 2 BBY or 1 BBY. Since nothing has definatively proven either year the entry should remain until new sources establish date of death. So the entry should be placed back on the list. Rac Ward
- He is definitively dead by the end of the Purge in 1 BBY, regardless of the specific date of death. Therefore he is in no way a survivor and should remain off the list. How he died is irrelevant. DD97Which bear is best? 07:07, November 16, 2010 (UTC)
How he died is not irrelevent. It establishes whether he was murdered by jedi hunters or whether he died of natural causes. In my previous post I mentioned he either dies in 2 BBY or 1 BBY. No source has established the definative date of death. Therefore without a specific year we can say that he was alive until 1 BBY or was known to be. Removing his name on some technical call is incredibly stupid. Rac Ward
- Why isn't irrelevant? This isn't a list of "Jedi who weren't killed by Jedi hunters", it's a list of Jedi who were alive when the Purge was declared over at the end of 1 BBY. I did notice you misinterpreted Halagad's date of death (which is defined as being somewhere between 2 and 1 BBY, not either/or), but I was going to let it slide. As you've decided to become obstinate on the point, let's review the fundamental reality of that statement; when the year 2 BBY begins, he's definitely alive, consequently by the time 1 BBY wraps up (and the Purge ends), he's definitely dead. This means at some point between the years 2 BBY and 1 BBY he did definitely die, and subsequently remained dead at the end of the Purge, which happens later. See? 3 BBY=Alive, 2 BBY=???, 1 BBY=dead, 0BBY=Purge over. For the record, declaring an opponent's argument "stupid" simply because you don't have either the evidence or debate skills to counter it isn't really a valid rebuttal, and skirts rather close to WP:NPA. Finally, wanting to force a personal fantasy regarding your favorite Jedi into the Star Wars canon is definitely a less valid reason than "mere" technicality. Consider this the end of the debate. DD97Which bear is best? 23:23, November 16, 2010 (UTC)
Final Warning
You've already broken WP:3RR, but it doesn't look like any admins have noticed, and I'm not going to tattle. However, if you do persist in attempting to add fanon to the article, I will bring this to their attention. I really don't want to, so don't force my hand. DD97Which bear is best? 18:26, November 17, 2010 (UTC)
You have been blocked from editing for 3 days for Edit warring. I, however, am showing you considerably less leniency based on the ridiculous degree of edit-warring you have shown this article over the past several days. If you continue to edit-war and insert fanon information when you return from your block, you will be blocked again for an extended period of time. Consider yourself forewarned. To contest this block, please contact the blocking administrator with the reason you believe the block is unjustified. Toprawa and Ralltiir 18:43, November 17, 2010 (UTC)
I wish to contest my ban, I am aware that the ban has been lifted but I feel that it was unwarranted. Rac Ward
Talk pages, again
Thanks for contributing to Wookieepedia! Before posting talk page comments, please familiarize yourself with the disclaimer at the top of talk pages, {{Talkheader}}. Talk pages are for discussion relating to changes to the article, not for a discussion about the topic in question. Thank you. Trip391 (talk) 04:12, May 15, 2014 (UTC)
Sourcing
Thank you for contributing to Wookieepedia! Please note that at least one of your recent additions added unverified information to a mainspace article. Additions to Wookieepedia's articles must be verifiable by a reliable source per our sourcing policy, and unverified information may be reverted or deleted. Continuing to add unverified information may lead to you being blocked from editing by an administrator. Thank you. You should know this by now. OOM 224 ༼༽talk༼༽ 16:09, 29 March 2021 (UTC)
All information I added to the article was established in canon sources, primarily the Jedi Fallen Order video game, in reverting the page you altered it by removing events already established in other canon sources such as Star Wars: Rebels, Star Wars: Jedi Fallen Order, and the Darth Vader comics. All sources verified and confirmed as officil Star Wars canon.