All posts by Chasemarc

I would fight against the empire, I was a law enforcement officer and EMT as well as a 9/11 first responder - i took an oath to protect my government against all threats foreign or domestic

So i would find Hera, Leia, sabine and the others and gladly join

I think of him like Angel from Buffy the Vampire slayer

ANAKIN (e1-e3) is one person the real ANAKIN Skywalker -- for buffy fans this is Liam Angel's human name

In episode 3 Palpatine "Sired" ANAKIN - turning him into the soulless Vader - aka Angelus the evil vampire

He remained this soulless creature till ROTJ

In ROTJ Luke returns ANAKIN'S soul to him making him a hybrid of Vader and ANAKIN (vaderkin)- this is Angel in Buffy

After the hybrid vaderkin dies, he is blessed by the force and regains ANAKIN Skywalker's full soul, letting him be his true self as a ghost

So is he the same person no, a "soulless demon" took over his body and memory, what makes him ANAKIN died in episode 3,

In my opinion it's the only thing that makes sense

None - give us an KOTOR Jedi and Sith - someone new

Filoni needs to take over

An Ewok, and 3 storm trooper walks into the forest

Only the ewok walk out

The other are "missing"

(sorry bad Storm trooper misses/Ewok eats people joke)

Both you can not have Vader without the Senate

Oola - the fact that they got the same actress to return to film Special Edition scenes was amazing

I like the Red Sith Stormtroopers

Twi'lek

But the cloners did not know about Palpatine's plans - they put the orders into the clones - would they have put a clause in the order that said:

"if the Republic is gone, follow whatever government takes it's place"

what if the CIS had taken control of Courascant - they would have control of Palpatine's office and could have given orders to the clone army. -- seems kind of dangerous to not be specific on the orders and what form of government can give the orders.

If the person joined the terrorist group because he or she had no other option (say it was "join or die") but has not committed any terror, they are still part of the terrorist group -

same with Gangs - you can be part of a gang yet have nothing to do with the gang activity.

or for college people you can be part of a Frat or Sorority and not do any of the parting/drinking/ other fun college stuff the other's do.

Just because you are part of something does not mean you do what they do - has any Sith Lord in Canon or in the old EU ever hid away and not committed any "Sith related evil deeds?"

True - but the original question

Say I'm a Sith - i was trained by Palpatine to be a Sith, but i disagree with his view on ruling the galaxy so i hide on a Hutt world (Palpatine then picks Maul to take my place) until the New Republic wins and then i go back into the main part of the Galaxy

Would they arrest me for believing the Sith way of life, for being trained by Palpatine? or would they say go enjoy being a Sith as long as you do not attempt to take over the galaxy like you master did.

Can you be a practicing Sith Lord and not be EVIL in the eyes of the Jedi and the Republic?

Windu was also a jerk IMO

His treatment of Ahsoka when the temple was bombed, and his treatment of Anakin - sorry but i was kinda happy he was tossed out of a 5,000 story window

Should have started with Attack of the clones, as Episode 1 with flashback of meeting Anakin

Then Episode 2 Should have been a clone war movie, that is 1.5 years after AOTC, with maybe more flashbacks of Anakin as a kid, meeting Obi and padme ect.

IMO the jump between Episode 1 and 2 make phantom kinda pointless, when from AOTC till ROTS, even from ROTS to ROTJ flows into each other if you watch the cartoons and everything else.

The large gap in time is my issue

The Jedi is a "religious type" of an order - they are space monks for lack of a better term. the Sith are the counterpart to the Jedi order

The Jedi belief system is the Light of the Force (aka God)

The Sith belief system is the Darkness of the Force (aka God)

For the "in-Universe" people it is not hard to think that the Jedi and Sith are religions, and if the Jedi wanted to END the Sith line - it would be exterminating a Religion in the eyes of the Galaxy

As far as what the Sith stands for - the people in universe would not know this YET, they would only know what the Jedi (the group that wants the other-side GONE) tells them

Look at the real world - the 3 major religions have been against each other for 2000 years, yet they are all fighting over the same plot of land and worship the same God - only the way they worship that God is different

Now to put that in Star Wars universe: the 2 major religions (Sith and Jedi) have been against each other for 20,000 years, yet they are all fighting over the same plot of land (the Galaxy) and worship the same God (the Force) - only the way they worship that God (the Force) is different (Light and Dark)

I do not want to believe this, James you will be missed, we will always love you and we will never forget you

So still a dead or dying race, and given they created the clones and reshaped the galaxy that was glossed over in the Bad Batch

Yea the showed the planet being bombed, but it was more then that..

So with Nala Se dead is her whole race now extinct?