71 Votes in Poll
His origin doesn’t matter, it’s his actions that do. I’m not about to feel sorry for a guy who’s a ruthless, merciless warlord and someone who goes around enslaving/torturing people.
If you really think about it in depth, going through the backstory of his life, Grievous in reality emerges as quite the tragic figure.
A proud and powerful warrior, fiercely loyal to his people and his world, who through the machinations of others, ended up as a victim of circumstance, rather than the one-note, one-dimensional, snivelling coward the depictions coming from a certain corporation would have you believe; all cackle and no kill, running away when the poodoo hits the turbofan.
He rose to prominence as Warlord of the Kaleesh when he led his subjugated and oppressed people in an uprising to liberate themselves from submission at the hands of the invading Huk species (who had caused the death of Grievous's main wife), even when the Huk had technological superiority over the more primitive, tribal Kaleesh. For freeing his people he was hailed as a hero on Kalee, but also drew the attention of Darth Tyranus, and through him Darth Sidious.
Grievous at first rejected Dooku's entreaties to become involved with the military forces the latter was establishing with his separate Confederacy of Independent Systems, preferring to remain with and dedicate himself completely to his people. It was only after the Sith Lords arranged for Grievous to fall victim to a shuttle crash in which he ended up mutilated and mangled, injured beyond repair, that things changed.
Grievous's life was saved thanks to the leadership of the CIS, at the cost of losing most of his organic body, and of course he was made to believe that the crash had been caused by agents of the Galactic Republic, filling him with the rage and thirst for vengeance that drove him to willingly ally with Dooku. During his war against and eventual invasion of the Huk, the Republic had sided with the Huk, originally creating Grievous's resentment of the Republic and the Jedi that would only continue to grow over time.
Grievous ended up a warlord once again, now leading the forces of the CIS in his quest for retribution on a Republic he had been manipulated into believing was responsible for stripping away what his life had been. I believe it was after the shuttle crash that he adopted the moniker of Grievous (his original birth name is Qymaen Jai Sheelal), although I might be off on that, it's been a long, long time since I read that issue of the SW Insider.
Speaking of the CIS military, also a well-deserved mention to Sev'rance'tann (core name Vrancet), a criminally underrated but highly interesting Chiss who was not only Grievous's direct predecessor as Supreme Commander of the Confederacy's Armies, but also Darth Tyranus's Dark Acolyte; worth doing some research on, as is the Chiss Ascendancy as a whole!
I’m a pacifist who believes that everyone can become a better person as long as they live.
So I would. Whether it would work or not I don’t think it would. But I would try. I may attempt to put him in captivity to work through his problems in a way which is safe for both of us and in the heat of the moment I doubt either of us would be think straight.
And if in the end it does not work I would still try to help.
^^ He stopped being tragic when he decided to reverse the situation against the Huk and wanted to exterminate them. He should have stopped after he threw them off planet. But no he went further and started killing indiscriminately on the Huk.
Two wrongs don’t make a right. I’ll sympathize with Grievous up until that point, but everything he does after outweighs that.
According to his Legends Wookieepedia page:
The Geonosians would also alter his brain against his wishes, to trim away disturbing memories while enhancing his rage centersBased on this I argue that combined with the obvious physical alteration, the old, more sympathetic Grievous died in the accident and that the new Cyborg version is essentially a Separatist-puppeteered zombie as far as ethics are concerned. I think a case could even be made that Obi-Wan Kenobi did him a service by killing him.
I think that I would only reach out for him for the sake of his wives, his children, and the kaleesh planet. If he only knew that joining the sith would have been the worst choice. But the best and only way to help this...general, is to kill him, releasing him. He wanted to die while he was in the bacta tank, anyway.
What do you think?