Come on, Ponda boba’s is Iconic

I have to vote for Maul, 'cause... Obi-Wan got a lot more than just his lower limbs. Well, that actually depends on your definition of "leg". Hmmmm.

Edit: it is also notable that this dismemberment was meant to be fatal and probably very painful. The other ones were meant to terminate combat without directly ending a life, Vader's included.

^ He lost everything from his waist down, so…

That he did, bois, That he did.

Also Vader became a sleek cyborg, but Maul became a rambling, shambling space spider. How is this a contest :)

I wasn't expecting Darth Maul to win, but rather Darth Vader, for this one.

Was it satisfaction to see Maul lose his legs for some?