Yeah I don't remember being scared by these, even the first time.

As a kid, Luke being trapped with the rancor was scary, followed by the trash compactor scene. Perhaps the exogarth was kind of creepy but I usually fell asleep on the movie at that point. 🤭(okay so my hot take is that Episode V had pacing issues!) The other scenes aren't scary. Mace Windu's death is tragic.

OH! Wait! As a kid i found the Geonosian scenes in AOTC where Anakin and Padme were in that droid factory and the arena scene scary, i kept screaming lmao and the scene in ROTJ with Jabba and Luke and all that was scary to me too lolll...

Actually, now that I think about it, the scene where the Ewoks were about to cook up Han Solo was kind of unsettling to me when I was younger.

The scariest one for me over all was when Vader became Vader cause I was 5 years old and Vader was the scariest person ever

I don’t really get scared that much. But I may have to choose the rancor scene. Even though the effects are very cheesy.

Anakin killing the younglings.

In my opinion, @Super Nerdd is the closest... The burning of Anakin/Vader on the banks of Mustafar...

Out of these, Anakin killing Seps- we're so used to bad guys being there to be killed by the good guys, and suddenly its 'Oh, he's actually going overboard this time'

When I was little, I was terrified by Sidious' UNLIMITED POWER!!! line. I thought the villains won, and sure enough, they did. Before that I thought that the heroes always won.