I pretty much love all of his live action appearances. His animated version in Rebels was subpar at best. The plot demanding that Kanan and Ezra survive is no excuse for nerfing Darth Vader in any way. Btw I wouldn't have included Obi Wan Kenobi in this poll if I were you because we're not allowed to talk about it outside of the official episode discussion post yet.

Original Trilogy

Rogue One

Obi-Wan Kenobi

Rebels

Revenge of the Sith

Pssh I'm a sucker for our Darth Lord of the Sith and savior all day, every day. Though it's one of those instances where it's usually an agreeable opinion, unless you're one of the few who think Vader sucks or is overrated. Not gonna lie, I enjoyed Vader in Rebels more than in Rogue One, which is ironic because the ending scene was just...so good. Rebel Soldier: "Help us!" If nothing else, it's probably because of the different stories being told. Original Trilogy will always be the best, though.

Obi-Wan is to-be-determined, since we've yet to see how this story ends, but I kind of like what we've seen so far, even though there are some negatives here and there. But hey, even as a diehard fan of Revenge of the Sith, there is..."NOOOOO!"

Bottom line: I'm a sucker for Darth Vader.

I wish comic was an option, I love how he’s depicted in his series.