Villan, I always imagined what if episode 9 took a twist and she joined Palpatine instead and then Ben solo had to eventually re-unite the resistance it could lead to a whole new trilogy and be an amzing twist that could have invited more sequel fans.

^It's funny. I thought about it too, but I imagined everything in much darker colors. The complete death of the Resistance and returning of the Sith Empire.

I would like that to, a trilogy of sith it would feel like the Old Republic.

I don't really think her character would work as a villain

Either way honestly had a plan were to have been made.

I say Hero

I mean when she was Rey she was good as a hero

I never did her being a villain

While we did see her a Dark Rey, I think a hero suited her more

Anti-villain. Have her be the new leader of the Knights of Ren and fight radical elements of the First Order/Final Order and the New Republic as well as crime syndicates and other rival factions that took advantage of the breakdown of New Republic infrastructure.

Dude. You can’t join let alone lead a Sith cult gang and at the same time claim to be the one to go after the radical elements. The Extremes of the Final Order would be up their alley but the First Order, who keep in mind were written to be moronically evil, would seem too moderate for them. If anything they’d try to purge the First Order and the Resistance for being extreme republicanists, for the Americans I’m not talking about the party I’m talking about the ideology which seeks to establish a Republic.

^The Knights of Ren are not the Sith nor are they bound by a set credo or dogma other than the veneration of the dark side and are generally more flexible in terms of their outlook. Hence why in Crimson Reign, they allied with the Crimson Dawn against the Empire and assisted the Sith Eternal cult and the First Order when it was in their interest to do so.

Should their leader judge the actions of either faction to be damaging to their own interests or ambitions then naturally they would I don't see how this would be a contradiction.

^lol yeah the puppets of Palpatine that were affiliated with the Final Order are totally not Sith. Look I don’t enjoy the Sequel Trilogy but I understand the factions at play.