The Inquisitorius, but to be honest, don't really like either.

Inquisitorius. To me a good logo should be something that coveys identity, is memorable, simple and aesthetically appealing and finally easy to replicate. The Shadow Collective logo by contrast is way too busy.

The Shadow Collective is ridiculously over designed. I’ll have to go with the Inquisitorius symbol because it’s simple and easily recognizable.