Live action or animation has never been a preference determining factor for me because whether a Star Wars movie/tv series is live action or animated doesn't determine it's quality for me. A well written animated series/movie can topple a poorly written live action series/moive for me and vice versa. For example, I prefer season 1 of the Bad Batch over season 1 of the BOBF, because despite the excessive amount of cameos in both shows I feel like the Bad Batch did a better job of (mostly) keeping the focus of the series on the Bad Batch. Anyways I'm going to vote for live action purely because we started this Star Wars journey with live action movies.