Hello.

There are spolier protocols in the community guidelines that will explain how to format spoiler threads.

If you are quick, this could be the discussions thread for Brotherhood.

I'm just going to find the link for you. I got 404 error on it.

Maybe put some spaces between the warning and the text.

Is that the battle of Yerbana? No sure, this book was just after Geonosis wasn't it, Yerbana was later? Can you remember the chapter that mentions it? I'm going to go back and see if I can find it.

There is a continuity note on the Brotherhood page.

What did you think of the book? I enjoyed it but it's not much more than a TCW arc. Some nice expansion of background behind some of the key decisions in ROTS.

I guess the Separatists invaded Dantooine just a few months or weeks after First Battle of Geonosis,and the battle lasted months and ended around 21 BBY

Sounds like it would work.

Soo did this become the Brotherhood thread?

Seems so.

I just finished the book today. Loved it!

It seems like Mike Chen mentioned a few things from the legends continuity;

As you mentioned Mace Windu and Dantooine; there isn’t a mention on how long the battle there went on or if there was more than one battle on Dantooine.

Another subtle reference I immediately connected was Ki-Adi-Mundi has a scar from his encounter with General Grievous, which could be Hypori but it wasn’t specifically stated. Just that it was from an encounter with Grievous.

Another Legends character that made a small appearance was Siri Tachi at the Knighting Ceremony indicating she had a Padawan being elevated to Knighthood. Could be Ferus Olin or it could be a whole other character but as soon as I saw her name I was hoping Ferus Olin would be mentioned. And also Olana Chion was named dropped as another Padawan being Knighted.

The storyline was a 10/10 in my opinion. Only disappointment was the epilogue wasn’t Mill Alibeth. A flashforward to the Attack on the Temple witnessing Anakin killing the Jedi would’ve been cool and possibly her escaping. Mill Alibeth was pretty cool. While I like the path she took, I do hope she does make a lightsaber. While Anakin and Mill’s connection is different than Anakin’s and Ahsoka’s, it shows Anakin was fit to teach even if he didn’t want to.

Mace Windu’s attitude towards Anakin was a great touch. How it had began immediately and not just in the Clone Wars or in Episode III. Makes you wonder even more how things may have gone differently if Obi-Wan or Yoda were on Coruscant when Palpatine reveals he is a Sith to Anakin.

Obi-Wan, of course, was a standout. His thoughts on Anakin and Padmé, Him and Satine, him and Anakin, Qui-Gon, him being on the council all of it was great. It also shows that he suspected Anakin and Padmé early on but kept it quiet even when he thought he should inform the council.

As I said I give the book a 10/10.

It was confirmed a while ago in The Clone Wars since it's mentioned.